On Dr. Elsa Schieder's blog, she recently asked her readers the following questions:
How best do we reach lots and lots more people with all this information, people currently resistant to it?
I have a slightly different question: What has worked best for you? Maybe especially, do you have any surprise success stories?
I also have a second question: Is there any resource, help, assistance, that you would especially like, in your counter-jihad efforts?
She published 22 of the answers, and some of them are quite good. You can read the answers here: Strategies for Getting Heard.
If you have some answers to these questions you would like to share with your fellow counterjihadists, you can always add them here (and read the answers given so far): Talk About Islam Among Non-Muslims.